I wish it was Terraria 2. I've been defending T2 on the basis that it was going to be a different game and not distract fans from Terraria. This is a disservice to both of those games. Effort that could have been spent on either funneled into a diet lime version of his greatest work. I don't understand why anything new from this game couldn't be implemented in either Terraria or Terraria 2, especially given that Red is actively working on adding content to Terraria. If it's just a new art style put out an official reskin patch!
I don't understand, also, why Red would want to lock himself into a Terraria do-over. I thought the plan was to move on to other genres, and for people to be playing Terraria for years after he finished, not jumping from new game to new game while this board devolves into bickering about which game does cabins better. Terraria's not even finished and he's kicking it to the curb for a new window model.