A problem

Pixel

Terrarian
I'm not entirely sure you should be 'dissing' people about making a suggestion. Look, they may not be the most original, but the majority of these thread creators are unaware. I guess they should probably take a good look in the search bar, but more new members tend to create these suggestions over the experienced ones who have thoroughly read through the forum rules.
 

Leinfors

Quality Assurance
Staff member
Moderator
Re-Logic
There is a pretty significant backlash against True Terra Blade suggestions, but the concept itself is not against the rules, nor will unconstructive kneejerk rejections "just because its TTB" be allowed.
 

Pixel

Terrarian
There is a pretty significant backlash against True Terra Blade suggestions, but the concept itself is not against the rules, nor will unconstructive kneejerk rejections "just because its TTB" be allowed.
Very well said, Leinfors. I have also noticed backlashes against Cthulhu boss or mechanization of BoC suggestions, but the truth is, it isn't against the rules, and they shouldn't receive threats and screams from the community.
 

Leinfors

Quality Assurance
Staff member
Moderator
Re-Logic
The only suggestion type which is specifically against the rules is a "full body Cthulhu". Everything else is perfectly justified getting fair assessment, and "ten bad TTB" threads doesn't mean the next one will be as well.

I personally am completely in support of a TTB, I'm not sure what the objection is.
 

Jofairden

Duke Fishron
tModLoader
There is a pretty significant backlash against True Terra Blade suggestions, but the concept itself is not against the rules, nor will unconstructive kneejerk rejections "just because its TTB" be allowed.

And to be honest, the concept isn't bad either.
 

Pixel

Terrarian
The only suggestion type which is specifically against the rules is a "full body Cthulhu". Everything else is perfectly justified getting fair assessment, and "ten bad TTB" threads doesn't mean the next one will be as well.

I personally am completely in support of a TTB, I'm not sure what the objection is.
Yeah. I assume members are against the idea because it seems too overpowered, and seems to be a repetitive concept. All in all; things shouldn't have to end up like this.
 

Nev

Queen Bee
Just out of curiosity, why is the Cthulhu boss against the rules? There's obviously been some drama about it which I have missed.
 

Gotcha!

Pumpking
I am wondering this as well to be honest. What gruesome event happened that made these suggestions banned? Why have different rules for cthulhu suggestions?
If people are asked to ignore terrablade threads rather than try to burn them down, wouldn't the same apply for cthulhu threads?
It feels like double standards are applied. :indifferent:
 

BFlat

Headless Horseman
Ok yes I know I was wrong. But either milt/baconfry made a thing like this, however they didn't get hate. Is that because they are popular? If that is the reason then I want to have nothing to do with this community anymore.. Because corrupt communities are bad.
 

Bethany

Empress of Light
I know there's a dispute over whether or not copyright has lapsed on some of H.P. Lovecraft's Cthulhu-mythos stories. It could be that his estate is protective of its IP rights. That's a guess only, I've no idea whether it's related.
 

MegaMage314

Plantera
Ok yes I know I was wrong. But either milt/baconfry made a thing like this, however they didn't get hate. Is that because they are popular? If that is the reason then I want to have nothing to do with this community anymore.. Because corrupt communities are bad.
If they made a suggestion like that, everyone would know it's a joke and the thread would get locked because joke suggestions aren't allowed.
 

BFlat

Headless Horseman
If they made a suggestion like that, everyone would know it's a joke and the thread would get locked because joke suggestions aren't allowed.
No they made a no cthulhu sprite
[DOUBLEPOST=1421791295][/DOUBLEPOST]
If they made a suggestion like that, everyone would know it's a joke and the thread would get locked because joke suggestions aren't allowed.
The only suggestion type which is specifically against the rules is a "full body Cthulhu". Everything else is perfectly justified getting fair assessment, and "ten bad TTB" threads doesn't mean the next one will be as well.

I personally am completely in support of a TTB, I'm not sure what the objection is.

If you go to milt's sprite thread, then go to the "other" spoiler you will see http://forums.terraria.org/index.php?threads/milt69466s-hammering-sprite-thread.5132/
 
I personally support one TTB-style suggestion- Tobbvald's Ria sword. Perfectly sprited and balanced. Also, Zoomo's motherboard is a good mechanical BoC suggestion.
 
Top Bottom