Portfolio/Multi-Topic I read the whole suggestions of the Terraria subreddit and arranged the top ideas, alongside my ideas

[AMIRHYBER🌳🤝🪓]

Oo nice dude I’ve been making a document compiling suggestions from the forums and posting links of the users would you like to help

Yes,of course

 

[AMIRHYBER🌳🤝🪓]

1. The formatting of this makes it so difficult to read.
2. Many of these just say "cool idea" or "original post" with a link, and no other description.
3. There are so many. Please take the similar concepts and post them together as smaller posts rather than one big oneI agree is that it needs another heavy editing

1. The formatting of this makes it so difficult to read.
2. Many of these just say "cool idea" or "original post" with a link, and no other description.
3. There are so many. Please take the similar concepts and post them together as smaller posts rather than one big one.

I agree that it needs another heavy editing.
About the posts with links.I was supposed to bring every top suggestions from Terraria subreddit till May 2nd ,and I did that.
Those that I wrote "cool idea" are things that I thought need no more explanation and are straightforward.
I included the links to credit the owner and so people could go to that original posts and read the comments.
I will do another overall editing but posting them as smaller posts is just so much.
It might be counted as spamming.
I could break them in 4 posts which would be.
1-Small suggestions.
For example event bosses masks.
2-Medium suggestions.
Addition to events
3-Big suggestions.
alternative hallow biome and its additions
4-Hard suggestions(those last 9).

 

[Modding Salmon]

Yes,of course

Nice I’ll give you the doc on Twitter do you have a discord ?

 

[AMIRHYBER🌳🤝🪓]

Nice I’ll give you the doc on Twitter do you have a discord ?

Yes

 

[Aceplante]

I agree that it needs another heavy editing.
About the posts with links.I was supposed to bring every top suggestions from Terraria subreddit till May 2nd ,and I did that.
Those that I wrote "cool idea" are things that I thought need no more explanation and are straightforward.
I included the links to credit the owner and so people could go to that original posts and read the comments.
I will do another overall editing but posting them as smaller posts is just so much.
It might be counted as spamming.
I could break them in 4 posts which would be.
1-Small suggestions.
For example event bosses masks.
2-Medium suggestions.
Addition to events
3-Big suggestions.
alternative hallow biome and its additions
4-Hard suggestions(those last 9).

Well as mentioned, there are many different ideas here that make no sense all thrown together into one mega post like this. If there is an idea that has not been posted yet here on the forums (and has only been posted on some other site), feel free to reshare the idea here and include a link to the source if you want. If an idea is already here on the forums, do not repost the same idea.

As for the links that just say "cool idea", the problem is we cannot tell what the idea is without clicking the link. And there are DOZENS of vague links in your post that have no explanation.

 

[AMIRHYBER🌳🤝🪓]

Well as mentioned, there are many different ideas here that make no sense all thrown together into one mega post like this. If there is an idea that has not been posted yet here on the forums (and has only been posted on some other site), feel free to reshare the idea here and include a link to the source if you want. If an idea is already here on the forums, do not repost the same idea.

As for the links that just say "cool idea", the problem is we cannot tell what the idea is without clicking the link. And there are DOZENS of vague links in your post that have no explanation.

Thanks for the recommendations
I will try to add some sort of description in front of every links without descriptions
Or just use the link itself as the description

 

[Enter_Name]

I read up to about 18, thought I was close to done, then gave up lmao. Only skimmed through some other parts so sorry if I repeat something already mentioned, but these are my thoughts;
As much as I would want more bosses, the amount mentioned is just too many in my opinion. The space sounds cool but as someone who never many arenas, this would be annoying to fight unless it's easily beatable in the room of a sky island. I have a similar problem with the spider nest one and desert one, being a cramped room full of webs/corridors. Many biomes seem too small to have a boss such as graveyard, oasis, aether, ect. A graveyard biome also is not naturally generated and a meteor boss existing would make me want a hollow boss since both generate at a milestone. I love the idea of adding things to the marble and granite biomes, as I get excited every time I see it just to remember they're useless and dangerous. The goblin army is quite easy and the other wave based events that dying doesn't end it are the same, a boss at the end could be nice. A lot of the other suggestions seemed much smaller and generally QoL additions or other things that most people would agree on.

 

[AMIRHYBER🌳🤝🪓]

I read up to about 18, thought I was close to done, then gave up lmao. Only skimmed through some other parts so sorry if I repeat something already mentioned, but these are my thoughts;
As much as I would want more bosses, the amount mentioned is just too many in my opinion. The space sounds cool but as someone who never many arenas, this would be annoying to fight unless it's easily beatable in the room of a sky island. I have a similar problem with the spider nest one and desert one, being a cramped room full of webs/corridors. Many biomes seem too small to have a boss such as graveyard, oasis, aether, ect. A graveyard biome also is not naturally generated and a meteor boss existing would make me want a hollow boss since both generate at a milestone. I love the idea of adding things to the marble and granite biomes, as I get excited every time I see it just to remember they're useless and dangerous. The goblin army is quite easy and the other wave based events that dying doesn't end it are the same, a boss at the end could be nice. A lot of the other suggestions seemed much smaller and generally QoL additions or other things that most people would agree on.

Thanks
When I wrote this I didn't think any of these would ever be considered.
However because most of these were fan favorites and were popular posts.
Some of the are already coming to the 1.4
5.
Around 4 or 5 I think.
I never expected Re Logic to add all of these
That's why there couple of unbalanced things
And I don't want to delay 1.4.5 in any way
you are absolutely right about too much bosses for smaller biomes.
If they are ever considered to be added.
Maybe we can add mini bosses for them
Like the Dreadanulist.
However I think he should be an official boss.
But for spider cave,Oasis,Graveyard and Aether and such biomes.
We can add mini bosses with easy spawn conditions.
For example for the spider biome.We can add something similar to queen bee larva,Queen Spider Egg,which if the players break it,she will spawn.
And her drops will be similar to the current Dreadanulist which is a mini bosses.
A mini boss doesn't need a lot of loot like a boss.
There are quite a lot of mini bosses in terraria already.
Honestly what I want most from this list,is the having the remaining event boss masks and a recipe to being able to combine the Twins trophies into one.
I think it's a fair and balanced request.
Will not break anything as much as I'm aware.