Reforge This Weapon!

[First Boss]

Unreal AX50

Bone Bow (Terraria (Unused))
Bow (Ranged)

 

[Vella]

Sighted Bone Bow

Vodka (Polandball)
Technically a Broadsword (Melee)

 

[First Boss]

Sharp Vodka

Croissant (France)
Shortsword (Melee)

 

[Vella]

Massive Croissant

M1911 (L4D)
Pistol/Firearm (Ranged)

 

[Ivyss]

Powerful M1911

Shovel (several)
Shovel (melee)

 

[No. 1 Usagi]

...the same modifier two times in a row. That's a tall tale if I ever saw one!

Demonic Aymr

AX50
Firearm (Ranged)

I've had it happen before.

Light Shovel

Sword of the Creator (Fire Emblem)
Whip (Summon/melee)

 

[leafsaber47]

Godly Sword of the Creator

Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer (Melee)

 

[Vella]

Demonic Hammer

Tome of Inspiration (MLP: FiM)
Spellbook (Magic)

 

[leafsaber47]

Celestial Tome of Inspiration

Steel Nordic Spear (The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim)
Spear (Universal Only)

 

[Vella]

Pointy Steel Nordic Spear

Primitive Spear (Don't Starve)
Spear (Universal Only)

 

[leafsaber47]

isn't Pointy a modifier that spears can't get?

Ruthless Primitive Spear

M200 (Girls' Frontline ver)
Firearm (Ranged)

 

[Vella]

isn't Pointy a modifier that spears can't get?

Ruthless Primitive Spear

M200 (Girls' Frontline ver)
Firearm (Ranged)

Pointy is damage-only modifier, I think. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Frenzying M200

Tactical Shotgun (L4D one, not Terraria one)
Firearm (Ranged)

 

[First Boss]

Sighted Tactical Shotgun

DK Rap (Donkey Kong 64)
??? (Universal only)

 

[leafsaber47]

Pointy is damage-only modifier, I think. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Nope. It's a Melee specific modifier. Pointy can't be obtained on spears, despite the stat changes.

Strong DK Rap (it isn't funny, can make a kremling cry out for mummy)

Red Phasesaber (Terraria)
Broadsword (Melee)

 

[First Boss]

Broken Red Phasesaber

Shroomite Digging Claw (Terraria)
Pickaxe/Claw (Melee)

 

[leafsaber47]

Lazy Shroomite Digging Claw

Third Leg (Touhou)
Laser Weapon (Magic)

 

[Vella]

Masterful Third Leg

Artifact Platinum Battlehammer (Dwarf Fortress)
Hammer (Melee)

 

[First Boss]

Keen Artifact Platinum Battlehammer

Celebration (Terraria)
Launcher (Ranged)

 

[leafsaber47]

Awkward Celebration

M4A1 (Girls' Frontline ver)
Firearm (Ranged)

 

[Ganransu]

Broken M4A1

Melee Chromebook (custom weapon I found in a game)
Sword (Melee)