Reforge This Weapon!

[leafsaber47]

Terrible spear

(is a spear weapon)
nani

Demonic BFG 9000
(how ironic)

Golden Shower (Terraria)
Spell Tome (Magic)

 

[First Boss]

Taboo Golden Shower

Knife on a Knife (My mind)
Shortsword (Melee)

 

[_tenfictions_]

Large Knife On A Knife

Sunset Yellow Overdrive (Melee)

 

[First Boss]

Large Knife On A Knife

Sunset Yellow Overdrive (Melee)

(if that's a jojo reference, shouldn't it be SUNLIGHT YELLOW OVERDRIVE)
Legendary Sunset Yellow Overdrive

「Star Platinum」 (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders)
Stand/Minion (Summoner)

 

[Icybow73]

You get a shoddy「Star Platinum」!

Splat charger (splatoon)
Sniper (ranged)

 

[First Boss]

Rapid Splat Charger

「Golden Experience Requiem」(JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Golden Wind)
Stand/Minion (Summoner)

 

[leafsaber47]

Godly Golden Experience Requiem

Blunderbuss (King K. Rool's from DKC and Smash)
Firearm (Ranged)

 

[_tenfictions_]

Ruthless Blunderbuss

Amber Shower (spell tome)

 

[First Boss]

Taboo Amber Shower

Fly Swatter (A lot of places)
Broadsword (Melee)

 

[Icybow73]

Legendary fly swatter

Multicannon(lots of places I guess)
Ranged

 

[First Boss]

Unreal Multicannon

Fourth of july fireworks (America)
Ranged (Launcher)

 

[_tenfictions_]

Rapid Fourth Of July Fireworks

Radiant Ruby (spell book)

 

[First Boss]

Celestial Radiant Ruby

Broken Lightbulb (Somewhere)
Shortsword (Melee)

 

[Icybow73]

Broken broken lightbulb

Sky fracture (terraria)
Magic weapon

 

[No. 1 Usagi]

Celestial Sky Fracture

Galaxy Sword (Stardew Valley)
Broadsword (Melee)

 

[First Boss]

Legendary Galaxy Sword

Butcher's Chainsaw (Terraria)
Overpowered Pre-Plantera Chainsaw (Melee)

 

[leafsaber47]

Demonic Butcher's Chainsaw

Predator Bow (Crysis 3)
Bow (Ranged)

 

[Dark Sunshine]

Broken Predator Bow.

Neptune’s Glaive (Stardew Valley)

 

[RandomAxolotl]

shoddy Neptune’s Glaive

Imposters Knife (among us)
melee (obviously)

 

[Tibithia Σ]

Broken Imposters Knife

SPAS-12
Shotgun (Ranged)