Terraria Community Forums

Hmm. Well, it's true that I do some of my best work on my own.

I'm sort of the same, however, I've got a couple plans so massive that I don't think will ever get done on my own. I think we've just begun on one of them.

Eh, personally... I'm not too surprised. Admittedly, suggestions aren't really my forte, but - while me and Pixel get on real well, and he's a great guy, I'm not really a fan of the creation of somewhat closed-off social groups like that, among others. If the 'Suggesters Elite' want to get together, I think that's cool, but hitherto lesser or unknown suggesters should also be encouraged to join in.

Well trust is a huge factor. We don't want anyone spilling the beans to a project before it's finished. I don't think it's some Elite group, just a small group wanting to improve the game.

I'm not saying that elitism is their intention, but it could come about one way or another. It does come across that way, a little. For my end of the scale, TFC is in the same situation.

If privacy was the wish of the group, I honestly think a conversation (or set of) might be a better choice. And, not being funny - but who the heck would try and whip a suggestion out from under everyone's noses, anyways? Even if there was such a case, the culprit could easily be denounced and proven guilty by the other members of the group.

Because a suggestion can be more impressive if it's not leaked before it's posted. For example, if I had leaked what Confection was before releasing it, people would already be expecting what it could be. When it comes as a surprise, you don't miss out on those "first reaction" responses.

Also we have a few suggestions being talked about, but there's one big one at the moment. A PM is best for one suggestion.

I still don't believe people would leak a suggestion. Contrary to what most people believe, suggestions and RPs both follow a similar format - and for both, it seems a bit overkill to go around leaking 'crucial' data!