Captain Cthulhu
Terrarian
Please dear god. I know you can equip both at a time, but it's practically screaming to be a Tinkerable accessory.
Uhh... While accessories stack, preventing buffs stacking is simple and has been done with multiple accessories (star cloak, honeycomb, panic necklace), meaning you wouldn't get two FTS buffs nor would the paladin's buff stack twice. It would still be massively overpowered, but those aren't the issue. The issue for these is stats and individual bonuses.Keep in mind the only restrictions the game has when it comes to accessories is you can't have more than one type of wings.
If this were in the game, you'd be able to carry all three shields for a massive DEF boost. This is pretty much the same reason there's no Paladin's Shield + Frozen Turtle Shell combination or any further tinkerings with the Lava Waders.
The damage they take is subtracted from your armor, so if you had tons of armor it wouldn't do that much <_> Which is what most people have when they have paladin shield to begin with. Merp.Why would I ask to get my friends damages 24/7. Do I look masochist.