- So overall the weapon I used most in pre-hardmode were Thor's Hammer, as it's available quite early and with just a few Thorium deposits and some patience to obtain it. The weapon does quite good damage and can even pierce making it overall excellent. However I feel as easy as it is to obtain it should either do less, or be made harder to get.
- Also in pre-HM the items from the Dessert Traveler proved to be exceptional for when obtainable. The Wind Gust especially good for early invasions and multi target damage.
- The High Tide was also another pre-HM weapon that stood out to me. The effect was cool, and it was also quite useful in a crowd.
- The Bloodboil was also quite useful for single target damage as well as crowds as it pierced infinitely over your cursor and did consistent enough damage that it could DPS down bosses quite effectively. Night's Lament, however, came out as my favorite of the two, despite it lacking auto-fire. The effect was awesome and the damage output was quite insane.
- The Amber-Augmented Magik Staff was insanely useful all through pre-HM on its basis of being able to provide an ichor debuff, even though it did not last long.
- Overall my ranking of Pre-HM weapons that I used, just on a basis of preference, were: The Amber-Augmented Magik Staff, Night's Lament/Bloodboil, Wind Gust, Thor's Hammer, and the Jelly Pond Wand
Moving onto Hardmode:
- I found the hardmode-ore magic weapons to offer fairly good value for what they're made of. Particularly the Adamantite, Titanium, and Hallowed Staves. The attacks themselves were unique, well thought out, and quite powerful in their own rights.
- The Valadium Staff man...just...so, so, so good
- The Spectral Blade added some nice flavor as a proactive buff, as well as providing decent damage at close quarters, as well as its previous versions. Though I tended to not use them as much due to lack of auto-swing.
- The Chlorophyte Staff was just a solid DPS weapon
- The Black-Hole Cannon was honestly one of my favorite weapons due to the unique nature of it. And I felt it would be cool to have a further upgraded version if combined with, say a magnet sphere, that shot out projectiles at enemies while pulling them in, but that would likely be quite OP
- The Terrarium Sage-Staff. Get it.
- Dragon's Breath, see above.
Things I feel could be improved upon:
- A lot of the later staves could do to be auto-fire, just to match the progression in vanilla Terraria, but that's more of a personal opinion and in no way makes the weapons worse, as most that I'm speaking of can be fired as fast as you can click anyways.
- I feel like the Demon-Fire Blast wand could do with having a bit of a damage boost, as the other options available at the time almost all out perform it in the mech boss fights.
- Twin's Ire is just slightly underwhelming as a whole. I feel it could do with having a faster fire rate, perhaps do something similar to how the Phantasm works, but provide a lower damage number to compensate. I'm not very good at balance ideas so I don't really know what all could be done :/
- The Ragnarok mage weapons are unique and cool, but are out-performed by the Nebula Blaze massively in damage output. However, I feel this has a lot to do with the fact that the Nebula Blaze seems...odd, as it can crit for about 2k damage without having any buffs present, and even randomly ding in about a thousand damage on a regular hit for seemingly no reason.
- The Harbinger Set feels slightly lackluster. Seeing as Terrarium is fairly easy to get that far into the game, and the set bonus itself almost guarantees that you'll put yourself at a disadvantage in almost any fight. Meanwhile Terrarium's set bonus is god-like in the debuffs it will provide most enemies as well as the extra damage just being a guarantee.
- Which brings me to my next point, that I feel Terrarium is too easily obtained. Farming the Ectoplasm required takes almost no effort and the hardmode bars certainly aren't anything difficult to get ahold of either.
That overall is my thoughts of most of the weapons and armors that I actively used in the play through, seeing as it was a magic only type of deal I frequently did not touch armors or weapons outside of those lines. And none of my points are in a menacing way nor meant to discourage. This mod is fantastic and definitely my favorite one available. Keep up your amazing work Sam
I'll probably continue to post things like this as I go through the other classes. With melee being next on the list!