If you could remove one reaction from the forum, what would it be?

[Someone that needs help]

definitely magic, as said above, it has basically no major use, the other ones i've seen mentioned (angry, tree, axe, boulder) all have their respective uses, even if the tree vs axe ones are legacy

Boulder and tree are pretty useless compared to magical

 

[Ivyss]

Well, assuming I had to specifically pick one to get rid of, tree. I see no use for it, at all. It doesn't convey a thing. Even it's old name "terraria seal of approval" that could just be covered by the like react.

 

[Esther]

angry. Just almost never gets used,

I'm... going to have to say that I only use that and the other OGs due to my hatred of the newer reactions, which still feel unneeded.

 

[Green_Metaknight]

Right now, there is nothing that I have reacted to with Tree.

 

[Unit One]

I think this discussion shows just how hard it is to please everyone. Every single one of your opinions on this is valid. And yet, there are conflicting viewpoints and thoughts on the reactions. They were added because they were thought to be a fun addition, something new, something amusing.

Some like this one, some find that same one not needed. Some never use that one, others see that same one being used all the time. They’re there if you want to use them. The majority of the forum members likely don’t even think twice about their existence.

Again, your personal opinion is valid. Maybe you can also see that we aren’t able to please all of the people all of the time, and the reactions are silly and fun, meant to be an entertaining diversion, nothing more.

 

[vessal]

i would say its only used as a dislike really.

 

[Korok 🪓]

Tree. In my (Very biased because I like the axe more than tree) opinion, it is barely used. (In fairness, same goes for axe, magical, and boulder as well.)

 

[Seagull of Rage]

Tree. In my (Very biased because I like the axe more than tree) opinion, it is barely used. (In fairness, same goes for axe, magical, and boulder as well.)

Axe works as a way of saying you disagree with something or don't like it without saying your angry at it. The other ones make sense though.

 

[Heath04🌳]

Tree. In my (Very biased because I like the axe more than tree) opinion, it is barely used. (In fairness, same goes for axe, magical, and boulder as well.)

I doubt tree would ever be removed since that is the main reaction used by Redigit

 

[Green_Metaknight]

Axe works as a way of saying you disagree with something or don't like it without saying your angry at it.

It also makes it really easy to just axe react without explaining why, and take my word for it; it is NOT FUN to have someone axe react one of your posts without explaining why.
EDIT: And then there's the fact that whenever I bring it up, people just axe react because they think it's funny, even though it's not.

 

[Someone that needs help]

I think this discussion shows just how hard it is to please everyone. Every single one of your opinions on this is valid. And yet, there are conflicting viewpoints and thoughts on the reactions. They were added because they were thought to be a fun addition, something new, something amusing.

Some like this one, some find that same one not needed. Some never use that one, others see that same one being used all the time. They’re there if you want to use them. The majority of the forum members likely don’t even think twice about their existence.

Again, your personal opinion is valid. Maybe you can also see that we aren’t able to please all of the people all of the time, and the reactions are silly and fun, meant to be an entertaining diversion, nothing more.

Back when the mods had alright ideas

But I changed mine to the tree

 

[Seagull of Rage]

It also makes it really easy to just axe react without explaining why, and take my word for it; it is NOT FUN to have someone axe react one of your posts without explaining why.
EDIT: And then there's the fact that whenever I bring it up, people just axe react because they think it's funny, even though it's not.

It just means they disagree with you. It's that simple.

 

[Green_Metaknight]

It just means they disagree with you. It's that simple.

No. It really isn't. On one of my previous status posts, I said that I was changing my pfp and banner, and I showed what I was changing it to.
Someone reacted with axe, and I commented on the post to say that I had no idea why that person reacted with axe, and I said that I would never know if they never told me.
That comment also got axe reacts, and nobody else commented on it.

 

[Seagull of Rage]

No. It really isn't. On one of my previous status posts, I said that I was changing my pfp and banner, and I showed what I was changing it to.
Someone reacted with axe, and I commented on the post to say that I had no idea why that person reacted with axe, and I said that I would never know if they never told me.
That comment also got axe reacts, and nobody else commented on it.

It generally means you disagree with something. People being s doesn't really mean the entire reaction is bad.

 

[Someone that needs help]

No. It really isn't. On one of my previous status posts, I said that I was changing my pfp and banner, and I showed what I was changing it to.
Someone reacted with axe, and I commented on the post to say that I had no idea why that person reacted with axe, and I said that I would never know if they never told me.
That comment also got axe reacts, and nobody else commented on it.

They didn’t want you to change it