Gonna copy and paste what I've said in the Terraria Metroid Mod Discord, in which I've replied to a Tweet that has to do eith "something that will give you negative reception based on your response:
The Amazing Digital Circus, while is an incredible animation with the humor, nostalgic elements to it, and the colorful cast of characters, is the perfect representation of why the indie community is now showing signs of lacking in personality of the cast of characters in a show, and even the plot. Pommi, the young cute jokester everyone is making fanart of is an example of the typical "character with anxiety" that has a style that is usually cute, and some of the faces that she makes are purposefully made to drawn to make it meme material. While I don't know every single characters' name off the top of my head, you can expect what I'm talking about by the following character tropes:
- a character who is usually caresome towards the main protagonist (or a character similar to Pommi that has anxiety/depression) which can lead to fans shipping them whether they're a girl or not,
- a character who is usually not the stupid one per se, but the character where they have a "Berdly"- like personality where they seem to be self absorbed in themself and their style physically represents the opposite of their personality (the purple rabbit in this case in which he is sarcastic despite the design showing himself always smiling),
- the character who can be seen as the jokester of the show but mentally has something wrong with them (personalities akin to Deltarune's Jevil, Spamton, etc)
- with the show catching a nostalgic 90s feel. I know people like me wish that the times of back then can come back with a resurgence with a fresh coat of paint (Cuphead? A 70s-80s looking game), but in all honesty, they don't capture a hundred percent of how it was like especially since the "common meta" everyone's into is applied in the show.
This show is great, yeah. The pilot has been created very well And I will like to see more of it in the future, but nothing will stop you from looking at an indie animation and think if it's unique and in anyway cause every time I see em, it's too Familiar. I've literally talked to someone about this exact show recently and they've said too that the acting and stuff feels to similar to stuff that they've watched.