I got the Gilded Idol, along with five extra copies of Folv's Lost Blade. Please tell me I'm just unlucky, and that they aren't supposed to be that rare. I'm perfectly okay with a bit of grinding, but over forty bosses for one item seems a little bit excessive.
Okay, I was about to submit this, then I decided to test out the Terror Bark to see if it was that great and that it was really worth the grind. I tested it on the Eye, and it dropped another Retina. (I couldn't gauge how good they were exactly, too used to Starplate gear, I'll get the next level from Raider, Tide, and...Skeletron?)
Seriously, what's the drop rate for these things? I'm actually getting really curious and confused. If it's 1 in 10 like a trophy, then I just got unlucky and it's a great rate. If it's 1 in 40, then I have many questions. Most of these questions would be the word "why" repeated over and over.