How the heck did Starbound not get a mention for being overrated? For two whole pages as well.
Essentially, it talks big, but delivers little. Even in endgame, you're following the same routine you learnt from the very beginning: mine, make armor to stop being instakilled, acquire upgrade, fuse previous ore with coal to make alloy, make armor, get upgrade, next ore.
I would be fine with that if it happened sparingly. Don't get me wrong, when it's limited to bits at a time, I love myself a little mining. But this... this is a plate piled a mile high, and you're being told to eat it. No.
There's a lot else I could say, but I think my point is clear.
As for underrated, I would have to say The Stanley Parable looks as though it didn't get the attention it deserved. Your brain will be in a million pieces if you try to play out all the different endings...