Since I said I would tell my opinions about the list, I am going to now. Kinda forgot this existed lol. Anyways, this isnt all, just a few of them. We can talk about a few entries at a time, no need for all of them in one comment.
One thing I noted before and noting it again: I am not a professional weapon ranker, I am just someone who is speaking from their own experience and trying to give his 2 cents of opinions. My opinions or takes might not be correct for someone else like you or any other person in this thread, but we all play differently so it would be understandable if someone thinks a weapon is worse or better than how you or I say how it is. Just keep the discussion calm and I am okay lol
Anyways lets start
(by the way, after the breaker blade one, I realized how laggy my phone gets when I try to reply to your ranking posts, so I am not using the "quote" feature from now on)
Breaker Blade: C-
Very satisfying to one-shot weak enemies with, but its special ability is somewhat mismatched with the fundamental nature of the weapon. As large as it is, the Breaker Blade still has shorter range than most weapons from other classes, and short range is not a desirable trait for a weapon that's meant to be used as an opener. You can use it for the first few seconds of the Destroyer fight for amazing DPS, but outside of that it's probably worse than whatever weapon you killed the Wall of Flesh with.
I dont really agree to be honest. I think breaker blade is one of those weapons that gets undeserved disslike? I am not really sure. Though for me, Breaker Blade, while not the best, still a good weapon in early hardmode. C- tier seems uncorrect for this weapon.
I think the thing that makes the Breaker blade
kind of/slightly better than the Night's edge is that Night's edge cant kill early hardmode enemies in 1 to 2 hits, but Breaker blade can do that. If this ever drops in a melee run, I dont disslike what Wall of Flesh dropped for me. Like you said, it one shots weak enemies, which while early hardmode isnt full of, still good. Night's edge is safer to use due to it's 360° swing, Breaker blade is good to one shot the enemies.
I think it can get C+ for me. Isnt really any better than C-, but anyway.
"Sky Fracture: B+"
Nah. It is too slow to be viable against twins, and the projectiles just cant land on them. Not an awful weapon but there is better. Good for it's easy obtaining, though. B- from me maybe? I am not sure to where I can place it.
"Flying knife: B"
Why is this B? It is so sluggish to use, to the point where you dont feel like you are using the weapon. Like you said, this weapon is also mentally hurting to use, you are probably gonna get severe headaches while using this. Like I said, I am speaking from my experiences with the weapons, and I honestly cant stand this weapon. Its unique in its function, but I would rather use a Shadowflame knife over this on Mechs. C at best, for me. I don't know about "cheesing" strategies though.
"Golem fist: D+"
Nah. It is far worse than this. I would say, that this is not even a D+ for the stage you get this thing. You probably kill Golem with a Terra Blade or Vampire Knives, and those are infinitely better than this. Not even a competition. D-, not F because attacking with a pickaxe wouldnt be better than it.
"Terrarian: A+"
"Meowmere: B"
"Star Wrath: B-"
This is a multiple weapon review at the same time but it does not matter
Anyways so for the rankings and analysis section, how is Terrarian objectively better than Meowmere and Star Wrath? Well, Terrarian has homing and is probably the only unique Yoyo in the game. It doesnt even need a Yoyo Bag to be better. But Meowmere and Star Wrath has more range and Star Wrath's stars, despite being inaccurate, falls so fast and spread to a large area (I think?) that inaccuracy of them does not matter. Terrarian has more consistent damage, but Meowmere and Star Wrath lands projectiles so fast that they basically become the same as The Terrarian, maybe even better. I think Terrarian can stay A+, but I also think that Star Wrath and Meowmere should be highered up in ranking. I might be wrong, though.
"Celebration Mk2: A+"
"S.D.M.G: S+"
I would swap their ratings.
SDMG does not have any unique aspects, while Celebration mk2 has unique functions depending on the rockets it shoots (different coloured rockets, each has their own effect). Not only that but Celebration mk2 covers a large area in top of having insane damage numbers. SDMG can do a similar thing, but Celebration mk2's unique effects, insane damage number and large area cover makes me think that it is better than the SDMG which is just a faster firing gun.
Okay I am done lol, I would add more but like I said, there is not a need to put everything I have different takes on to one comment. We can focuse on more later. For now, I can discuss about these.
