Is Minecraft Steve or the Terraria Player stronger? I have the answer.
- Thread starter Lecic
- Start date
Lecic
Steampunker
Not KG. Grams. Look back at the post. Anyway, I could make the same argument with MC enderchests to terrarian safes/piggybanks. They don't count, because they store things in an alternate dimension.
And also, the super chest is completely doable in vanilla minecraft without any commands or third party tools, so I'd say it counts.
Suweeka
The One and Oni
I don't see a problem.
But yes, most definitely bring the enderchests in. Because that makes the weight portion of the equation undefined. What's left is the amount you can carry. In that case, a Terrarian would win.
ExoticCharm
Terrarian
I don't see how Steve is stronger. The terrarian player can hold 128 slots (50 initial + 40 from safe + 40 from piggybank - 2 for holding safe and piggybank) of 999 gold brick, but Steve can hold only 40 slots of 64 gold blocks. Techincally, the Terraria player seems to be holding these items in the containers, whereas the ender chest in Minecraft usess magic to transport items. Taking feet-to-meter conversion into consideration and negating cursor hold and armor (as both should be negligent), then we should have:
Terraria Player: (128 slots)*(999 gold bricks)*(2 cubic feet) = 255744 cubic feet = 7242 cubic meters
Steve: (40 slots)*(64 gold blocks)*(1 cubic meter) = 2560 cubic meters
Terraria player wins if you ask me.
Terraria Player: (128 slots)*(999 gold bricks)*(2 cubic feet) = 255744 cubic feet = 7242 cubic meters
Steve: (40 slots)*(64 gold blocks)*(1 cubic meter) = 2560 cubic meters
Terraria player wins if you ask me.
Lecic
Steampunker
If I take a piggybank, put it down on one end of the world, and travel to the other end of the world, put down a completely different piggybank, and open it, my items from the other one will be there. Therefor, the Terrarian piggybanks and safes are just as magic as enderchests.
Anyway, we aren't going by slot total, we're going by total carrying weight, where Steve wins out.
totallydeadaccountdude
Terrarian
Physical strength doesn't necessarily mean ACTUAL strength.
As the Terrarian player uses stuff like Magic, Guns, Bows, Swords, Hammers, Shurikens, Throwing Knives, Laser Guns, Sickles, etc.
So he's obviously well-taught in the art of stabbing stuff.
Meanwhile Steve can only use a sword, axe, pickaxe, hoe, shovel, and bow.
Also, let's compare their height.
Terraria player's about 6 feet tall, while Steve is... doing some rough estimation here, judging by pictures... 5'8''-6'
That means that I'm as tall (or taller) than Steve.
So there isn't going to be any colossal giant stomping in the fight, which was damn obvious.
Now, let's compare swords.
LOOK at that difference! Now, I know what you're saying, "Oh, they're both supposed to be the same size, as Terraria uses 2x2 pixels!" ...well yeah... then we should do some MORE sword sizing.
That sword is pretty much going to curbstomp the Diamond Sword, now.
Here's the thing though, it isn't about size, but design.
Now, we're assuming that both Steve and the Terraria character have no armor, and are at their max HPs. (Steve at 10 hearts, Terraria dude at 500 HP) What blade is going to do the most damage?
The Terra Blade, without a DOUBT.
You see the Terra Blade shoots a magic projectile, which, at longer distances, effectively acts as a sword slice.
Good O'l Steve doesn't have that, just a sword to swing at enemies.
Now, finally, how SMART are they?
Now, to do this, is actually pretty easy. We just look at the kind of stuff they craft, how they function, and what they do.
Steve is the MacGyver of the Minecraft world. Able to craft razor(knight)-sharp swords with a stick and some rough, unclear diamond.
He knows his way around the Workbench, buuuuuuuuuuut... the Terraria player does too.
The Terraria player knows how to make spells, guns, hell, even cannons that shoot STARS at people. The Terraria player wins this by a long-shot.
Though what about communication?
Well, the Terraria player, once again, wins!
The Terraria character can sell stuff and buy stuff at a reasonable price, 50 silver for an anvil? That's borderline STEALING!
Meanwhile, Steve's trading 7 super rare emeralds for a pair of leather trousers he coulda gotten by just slaughtering a few cows.
So. Basically Terraria character wins. I guess. Idunno I wrote a lot of this in a rush.
As the Terrarian player uses stuff like Magic, Guns, Bows, Swords, Hammers, Shurikens, Throwing Knives, Laser Guns, Sickles, etc.
So he's obviously well-taught in the art of stabbing stuff.
Meanwhile Steve can only use a sword, axe, pickaxe, hoe, shovel, and bow.
Also, let's compare their height.
Terraria player's about 6 feet tall, while Steve is... doing some rough estimation here, judging by pictures... 5'8''-6'
That means that I'm as tall (or taller) than Steve.
So there isn't going to be any colossal giant stomping in the fight, which was damn obvious.
Now, let's compare swords.
LOOK at that difference! Now, I know what you're saying, "Oh, they're both supposed to be the same size, as Terraria uses 2x2 pixels!" ...well yeah... then we should do some MORE sword sizing.
That sword is pretty much going to curbstomp the Diamond Sword, now.
Here's the thing though, it isn't about size, but design.
Now, we're assuming that both Steve and the Terraria character have no armor, and are at their max HPs. (Steve at 10 hearts, Terraria dude at 500 HP) What blade is going to do the most damage?
The Terra Blade, without a DOUBT.
You see the Terra Blade shoots a magic projectile, which, at longer distances, effectively acts as a sword slice.
Good O'l Steve doesn't have that, just a sword to swing at enemies.
Now, finally, how SMART are they?
Now, to do this, is actually pretty easy. We just look at the kind of stuff they craft, how they function, and what they do.
Steve is the MacGyver of the Minecraft world. Able to craft razor(knight)-sharp swords with a stick and some rough, unclear diamond.
He knows his way around the Workbench, buuuuuuuuuuut... the Terraria player does too.
The Terraria player knows how to make spells, guns, hell, even cannons that shoot STARS at people. The Terraria player wins this by a long-shot.
Though what about communication?
Well, the Terraria player, once again, wins!
The Terraria character can sell stuff and buy stuff at a reasonable price, 50 silver for an anvil? That's borderline STEALING!
Meanwhile, Steve's trading 7 super rare emeralds for a pair of leather trousers he coulda gotten by just slaughtering a few cows.
So. Basically Terraria character wins. I guess. Idunno I wrote a lot of this in a rush.
ExoticCharm
Terrarian
But slots translate to the amount of weight you can carry. Also if you add the 27 slots from the ender chest, the Terraria player still comes out on top.
Lecic
Steampunker
Slots translate to the amount of total items you can carry, not the amount of weight. Did you even read the OP?
I'm not arguing for the enderchest to count, I'm saying neither the piggybank & safe nor the enderchest should count, since they're magical alternate dimensional storages or something.
Physical strength doesn't necessarily mean ACTUAL strength.
As the Terrarian player uses stuff like Magic, Guns, Bows, Swords, Hammers, Shurikens, Throwing Knives, Laser Guns, Sickles, etc.
So he's obviously well-taught in the art of stabbing stuff.
Meanwhile Steve can only use a sword, axe, pickaxe, hoe, shovel, and bow.
Also, let's compare their height.
Terraria player's about 6 feet tall, while Steve is... doing some rough estimation here, judging by pictures... 5'8''-6'
That means that I'm as tall (or taller) than Steve.
So there isn't going to be any colossal giant stomping in the fight, which was damn obvious.
Now, let's compare swords.
LOOK at that difference! Now, I know what you're saying, "Oh, they're both supposed to be the same size, as Terraria uses 2x2 pixels!" ...well yeah... then we should do some MORE sword sizing.
That sword is pretty much going to curbstomp the Diamond Sword, now.
Here's the thing though, it isn't about size, but design.
Now, we're assuming that both Steve and the Terraria character have no armor, and are at their max HPs. (Steve at 10 hearts, Terraria dude at 500 HP) What blade is going to do the most damage?
The Terra Blade, without a DOUBT.
You see the Terra Blade shoots a magic projectile, which, at longer distances, effectively acts as a sword slice.
Good O'l Steve doesn't have that, just a sword to swing at enemies.
Now, finally, how SMART are they?
Now, to do this, is actually pretty easy. We just look at the kind of stuff they craft, how they function, and what they do.
Steve is the MacGyver of the Minecraft world. Able to craft razor(knight)-sharp swords with a stick and some rough, unclear diamond.
He knows his way around the Workbench, buuuuuuuuuuut... the Terraria player does too.
The Terraria player knows how to make spells, guns, hell, even cannons that shoot STARS at people. The Terraria player wins this by a long-shot.
Though what about communication?
Well, the Terraria player, once again, wins!
The Terraria character can sell stuff and buy stuff at a reasonable price, 50 silver for an anvil? That's borderline STEALING!
Meanwhile, Steve's trading 7 super rare emeralds for a pair of leather trousers he coulda gotten by just slaughtering a few cows.
So. Basically Terraria character wins. I guess. Idunno I wrote a lot of this in a rush.
Yeah, no doubt there that the Terraria player has stronger weapons.
Jill
Official Terrarian
But... this is nothing to do with the relative merits of the games themselves.
This is just like a mini-version of the 'Death Battle' series if you know that. If you don't, this is just like saying 'Mario vs Sonic, who would win' or something like 'Sonic vs The Flash, who's faster'.
totallydeadaccountdude
Terrarian
That's like, your, opinion, man.
Jill
Official Terrarian
As excessive a belief as I think that is, you have your own right to hold it - however, you have no right to question the worthiness of threads or people who dare to mention it.
Metoot
Plantera
MegaMage314 🌳
Living Tree
I'm still going with the theory of hammer space:
Lecic
Steampunker
That's... literally where I got the number from. What are you trying to say? All I did was convert it from scientific notation to show *just* how big it is.
Metoot
Plantera
Number on this video has much more zeros
Lecic
Steampunker
The online calculator I used might have had an integer cap.
Looking back at the OP, that would explain why the second number is so similar in length to the first...
Let's be honest, it's an exploit that will probably be fixed and doesn't fit into the standards of Minecraft play. Also, forget the masses of craftables as stating that all that mass get's transferred into the product is not confirm-able. If you look at the cold hard facts of item stacks, 64 cubic meters of dirt obviously ways less than 1998 cubic feet of dirt.
Belph
Terrarian
The only real answer to this is: It doesn't matter, stop comparing the two games already, it was already old before Terraria was released.
You guys remind me of the guys arguing over Sailor Moon and Dragon Ball back in the nineties.
O__O this is new to me...there were really people out there back then who argued who was the strongest between Sailor Moon and Goku? oh gawd...