Kyouko Tsukino
Steampunker
Yeah. Those who hadn't read the SM manga would say Goku, those who were just looking for an argument would say Moon. It's quite likely they would both die if they fought - and then be revived because screw permadeath.
Is Minecraft Steve or the Terraria Player stronger? I have the answer.
- Thread starter Lecic
- Start date
Yeah. Those who hadn't read the SM manga would say Goku, those who were just looking for an argument would say Moon. It's quite likely they would both die if they fought - and then be revived because screw permadeath.
MegaMage314 🌳
Living Tree
Actually, it was a feature added for adventure maps and stuff, Minecraft has a bunch of those... I still don't think it should count though, as its just as "magic" as ender-chests and piggy-banks, if not more.
Ah, fair enough, my latter point still holds though.
well, no, Minecrat blocks are bigger than Terraria blocks. But the difference in stack size and inventory does make that difference obsolete.
Lecic
Steampunker
The ability to pick up blocks with NBT tags added to them isn't an exploit, it was a purposefully implemented feature of the vanilla game. No idea what you're talking about.
Gotcha!
Old Man
Steve has 36 inventory slots, stacks blocks to 64 and thus carries 2304 blocks, The Player can carry 40x999=39960 blocks.
Edit: Silly me. Terraria offers 50 slots, not 40. So that makes 49950 blocks.
Last edited:
Was already informed of this:
Like Mega said, it's still a 'magical' component and not a proper representation of physical prowess.
LoM2
Retinazer
Really.
I don't believe in a god, therefore other people shouldn't talk about religion. /sarcasm
Anyways, to the topic of the thread at hand: Not going into the numbers but I have to say Safes, Piggy Banks and EnderChests all don't count. If the items were LIMITED to the container they were placed in, then sure, count them, but considering they can be accessed from ANY PB/Safe/EC they appear to be in limbo or something.
Please don't respond to these types of messages. There's really no point in dragging back in off topic posts.
RainbowDrago
Plantera
The player can go TO SPPPPAAAACCCEE with 49950 blocks,
And he can also quad jump WITH BALLOONS and also FLY,
(He even flys faster UNDERWATER EVEN AT THE DEEPEST LEVELS OF THE SEA)
Oh I also forgot armor which can add more weight
I don't know the heaviest terraria armor so idontknow
While Steve just runs and jumps with some golden apples,and golden armor
Flying with 49950 blocks or jumping and running with golden apples
try to guess how much strength each task needs
Pretty sure that should be considered.
And he can also quad jump WITH BALLOONS and also FLY,
(He even flys faster UNDERWATER EVEN AT THE DEEPEST LEVELS OF THE SEA)
Oh I also forgot armor which can add more weight
I don't know the heaviest terraria armor so idontknow
While Steve just runs and jumps with some golden apples,and golden armor
Flying with 49950 blocks or jumping and running with golden apples
try to guess how much strength each task needs
Pretty sure that should be considered.
Lecic
Steampunker
Not golden apples.
Super massive chests full of chests, all the way down to the NBT depth limit, at which point they're full of extremely heavy banners.
GoldenTerrabyte
Old Man
Hmmm, some very interesting points here, however, nearly all games, including both of these, follow one rule of thumb...
Any and all things are weightless when stuffed in your pocket. With that said, Terrarians can defeat these huge monsters with huge weapons, but let's not forget Steve can kill massive monsters with pretty weak equipment(even all Diamond gear isn't so powerful) that CAN break, not to mention no health extensions!
Steve may still be stronger.
Oh, and Steve can swim up waterfalls.
Now I may have overdescribed Steve and barely described Terrarians.
Now, Terrarians rely on much more powerful equipment, but they also go up against much worse enemies! And Terrarians really can vary much more in strength, depending on what KIND of equipment they use.
I honestly think this concept has a ton of possible ways to look at it, so it's hard to say honestly...
Any and all things are weightless when stuffed in your pocket. With that said, Terrarians can defeat these huge monsters with huge weapons, but let's not forget Steve can kill massive monsters with pretty weak equipment(even all Diamond gear isn't so powerful) that CAN break, not to mention no health extensions!
Steve may still be stronger.
Oh, and Steve can swim up waterfalls.
Now I may have overdescribed Steve and barely described Terrarians.
Now, Terrarians rely on much more powerful equipment, but they also go up against much worse enemies! And Terrarians really can vary much more in strength, depending on what KIND of equipment they use.
I honestly think this concept has a ton of possible ways to look at it, so it's hard to say honestly...
MegaMage314 🌳
Living Tree
Oh yeah, Steve has the added advantage of actually being able to swim... and I guess we should also include the fact that Steve can still fight and forage without tools.
Dusty Sinclair
Headless Horseman
Doesn't matter. How do you know how much the fictional substances weigh?
Lecic
Steampunker
Because the materials exist in the real world, and the blocks in both games have a confirmed block size? Oak wood and copper aren't "fictional substances."
Dusty Sinclair
Headless Horseman
I mean redstone, netherrack, soul sand, mythril, demonite, chlorophyte, etc. Fictional substances. You know, the things in the games that don't exist in the real world. Nice try, though.
Lecic
Steampunker
Well, obviously we can't know, unless the devs outright say "this is the density of demonite" or whatever. So, we use things we DO know the weight of. Are you legitimately trying to discredit me for NOT using substances with no defined mass?