Items Sword of Discord

[GIRGHGH]

Sword of Discord

Ingredients: R.O.D. ; True Excaliber ; [something from after Duke Fishron]
Description: Teleports then enemy it hits to the cursor
65 Damage
Slow speed
4% Critical strike chance
Use to rid yourself of pesky enemies!
For bosses it just knocks them back, whether they want to or not!

 

[MegaMage314 🌳]

That does a lot of damage, you might want to lower it a little. you also didn't say how to obtain it, and there's a reason some enemies are immune to knockback.

 

[Frous]

mmm, it should hurt you over the attacks you do if you going tu put that beast damage

 

[Sdds Vitorias]

Hmmm, so i would loose my awesome teleportation skills by making an sword that teleport enemies? I prefer i teleport myself out of the situation

 

[Red H2O]

Let's just throw all the balance out the window. I mean, it's not like that's a bad idea or anything.

OT: If this is literally crafted as an Excalibur and a Rod of Discord, then I could make this very, very quickly after starting Hardmode (depending on skill, of course. But Hallowed Bars are not a rare commodity). That damage is utterly insane, and could get crits. in the range of the upper 600's easily. Lastly, most bosses are supposed to never have knockback affect them, as it would break their AI horribly and cheese the fight.

 

[GIRGHGH]

Let's just throw all the balance out the window. I mean, it's not like that's a bad idea or anything.

OT: If this is literally crafted as an Excalibur and a Rod of Discord, then I could make this very, very quickly after starting Hardmode (depending on skill, of course. But Hallowed Bars are not a rare commodity). That damage is utterly insane, and could get crits. in the range of the upper 600's easily. Lastly, most bosses are supposed to never have knockback affect them, as it would break their AI horribly and cheese the fight.

There are something you aren't seeing, it has no critical strike chance. Even with all crit accessories it would still only 20% crit. It also isn't even fast, with average speed. I'll add one more ingredient too. Oh, and make another material different.

 

[Baconfry]

More ingredients? I hate to say it, but this is better suited as an RNG drop. In my opinion, the crafting recipe is the weakest part of the suggestion. Excalibur? Why Excalibur?

The idea is interesting, but the execution needs a lot more work.

Also, denying a weapon a critical strike chance is a balance method that has never been used and should never be used.

 

[Desucrate]

I'm sorry, but I've seen from few of your suggestions that you cannot take criticism very well and are quick to defend your suggestions.
Everybody is trying to help give you better suggestions so that if they do get added into the game, it makes the game better than before.

 

[GIRGHGH]

I'm sorry, but I've seen from few of your suggestions that you cannot take criticism very well and are quick to defend your suggestions.
Everybody is trying to help give you better suggestions so that if they do get added into the game, it makes the game better than before.

I'm not defending my ideas from criticism, I'm giving peoples criticism criticism.

More ingredients? I hate to say it, but this is better suited as an RNG drop. In my opinion, the crafting recipe is the weakest part of the suggestion. Excalibur? Why Excalibur?

The idea is interesting, but the execution needs a lot more work.

Also, denying a weapon a critical strike chance is a balance method that has never been used and should never be used.

I changed the ingredients.

 

[MegaMage314 🌳]

There are something you aren't seeing, it has no critical strike chance. Even with all crit accessories it would still only 20% crit. It also isn't even fast, with average speed. I'll add one more ingredient too.

Usually its assumed that all weapon suggestions have a 4% base critical strike chance (like nearly every weapon in the game), unless its stated otherwise. changing it to a default of 0% doesn't make this weapon any less OP though.

 

[GIRGHGH]

Usually its assumed that all weapon suggestions have a 4% base critical strike chance (like nearly every weapon in the game), unless its stated otherwise. changing it to a default of 0% doesn't make this weapon any less OP though.

How about -20% critical?

 

[Frous]

ya nerf it to 96, and add 35 ichor and 35 adamantite bars and you are ready

 

[Red H2O]

How about -20% critical?

How... how would that even work? There's a 20% chance to do less damage? Does it heal enemies?

 

[GIRGHGH]

How... how would that even work? There's a 20% chance to do less damage? Does it heal enemies?

It makes it so that you can't have any critical strike chance at all unless you have EVERY Critical strike thing on you. More than just accessories.

 

[Baconfry]

I changed the ingredients.

It went from a bad crafting recipe to a very bad crafting recipe.

Why... why not an RNG drop?

And just give it a base 4% critical strike chance and bring the damage down, why don't you try that?

 

[MegaMage314 🌳]

It makes it so that you can't have any critical strike chance at all unless you have EVERY Critical strike thing on you. More than just accessories.

I think it would be easier to simply lower the damage

EDIT: wait... why did you add all the boss trophies to its recipe!?

 

[kageboushiKun]

ALL BOSS TROPHIES? Seriously, if you want to make it endgame, use a different method, like adding the duke fishron trophy or something.
Concept- good. Crafting recipe- no.

 

[GIRGHGH]

ALL BOSS TROPHIES? Seriously, if you want to make it endgame, use a different method, like adding the duke fishron trophy or something.
Concept- good. Crafting recipe- no.

Fixied.

 

[MegaMage314 🌳]

There shouldn't be ANY trophies in the recipie for a sword, that doesn't make sense and it just seems like a lazy attempt to justify its excessive damage.

 

[kageboushiKun]

Fixied.

I didn't mean it like that, the duke fishron trophy isn't a thing that should be used in a recipe, I meant it as in something that is obtained around the same time as the duke fishron trophy.