DicemanX
Brain of Cthulhu
Pumpkin Moon will always be easy to hit wave15. There's no reason to maximise potential on that apart from bragging rights. As for the Frost Moon, unless you are scattering a good amount of spear traps everywhere which I don't do, I don't see how the difference is huge. Even if it is the difference between getting from wave15 to 16 for an individual, I still don't find it huge.
I was merely pointing out that your claim that "the DPS difference between Menacing and Lucky is too small that it is negligible in realistic scenarios" is not accurate, and and a personal lack of desire for optimization won't change that. Furthermore, I said that the difference in crit boosts and damage boosts for Moon events CAN be huge, which is an easily demonstrable claim.